Baywood–Aragon · San Mateo, California

1242 Shafter Street

Price available upon request

A 1936 Colonial on a tree-lined street, with an open kitchen, a landscaped yard and a detached studio office — midway between San Francisco and Silicon Valley.

3Bedrooms
1.5Baths
~2,080Sq ft home
5,000Sq ft lot
1936Year built
StudioOffice · ADU potential

The Home

Classic character, thoughtfully updated

Behind the columned entry porch, the main level flows from a long living room with a brick fireplace, crown molding and plantation shutters into a formal dining room and an open kitchen and family room. French doors open to a flagstone patio and a private, hedge-lined yard.

Upstairs are three bedrooms, including a primary bedroom with a French door to a rear balcony. Across the yard, a detached studio with a vaulted, beamed ceiling, sliding glass doors, a mini-split and a kitchenette works as a home office, gym or creative space.

Open kitchen with island and family room with beamed ceiling

Kitchen & family room

White shaker cabinetry, farmhouse sink, stainless range and hood, patterned tile backsplash, and a navy island with seating, open to a family room with a beamed ceiling and built-ins.

Butler's pantry

Bar sink, wine refrigerator and glass-front cabinets between the kitchen and dining room. Powder room with side-by-side laundry on the main level.

Studio office

A detached, light-filled studio with exposed beams, sliding doors to the yard, a mini-split and kitchenette — room for a quiet workspace away from the main house. It could also be permitted as an ADU; see the option.

Outdoor living

Flagstone patio, turf lawn with a concrete-paver grid, planting beds, mature privacy hedges, a paver driveway and a broad front lawn.

Improvements

Work done since 2015

  1. 2016

    Engineered foundation stabilization

    Push-pier underpinning and re-leveling per engineered plans, with city permits and inspections. The pier system carries a transferable manufacturer's warranty. Full engineering and repair records are available to qualified buyers.

  2. 2016–17

    Kitchen and main-floor remodel

    Walls opened for the kitchen and family room, custom cabinetry throughout the kitchen, pantry, laundry and powder room, and a new front porch, walkway and retaining walls.

  3. 2021

    Backyard and studio

    Landscaped rear yard and patios, and the garage remodeled into the detached studio office.

Floor plans

How it lays out

Tap a plan to open it full size. Measurements are approximate and not guaranteed; buyers should verify.

Main floor plan: living room, dining area, kitchen, family room, half bath and foyer
Main floor
Upper floor plan: primary bedroom, two bedrooms, bath and hall
Upper floor
Basement plan
Basement
Detached studio plan
Detached studio

View all floors on one page · Floor plans by Monty Lou Media Group.

Room to grow

Option: 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths and an ADU

Today the home has 3 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, plus a detached studio. Under current City of San Mateo rules, a buyer could take it further in two steps: permit the studio as an accessory dwelling unit (ADU), then add a primary suite above the single-story family room. The result would be a 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath main house with a separate ADU.

Aerial view of the back of the house, the yard and the detached studio. Marker 1 is on the studio at the back of the lot; marker 2 is on the flat roof of the single-story family room.
  • 1Detached studio: could be permitted as an ADU
  • 2Single-story family room: a primary suite could be added above it

1Studio to ADU

The studio has about 320 sq ft inside, a vaulted, beamed ceiling, sliding doors to the yard, a mini-split and a kitchenette. Adding a bathroom and a full kitchen would let it be permitted as an ADU for guests, extended family or rental income.

  • Converted in place: San Mateo requires no new setbacks to convert an existing accessory building on its current footprint.
  • No replacement parking is required when a garage is converted to an ADU.
  • ADUs that meet the standards are approved by City staff, without a public hearing.
  • The wall along the side property line would need fire-rated construction.

2Primary suite: 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths

Build a primary bedroom of roughly 200 sq ft above the single-story family room, and turn the bedroom beside it into the suite's bath and walk-in closet. The current primary bedroom divides into two bedrooms, each with a closet and window, and the hall bath is renovated. The half bath stays downstairs.

  • The family room was added under a 1967 City permit, so the suite would sit on an existing footprint.
  • Second-story additions go through City planning review; additions of 200 sq ft or less follow a simpler process.
  • A structural engineer would confirm the family room's foundation and framing can carry a second story.
Studio floor plan today: one room 14 feet 3 inches by 17 feet 8 inches, plus a 3 foot 9 inch by 17 foot 8 inch side area
Studio today · about 320 sq ft
Upper floor plan today: primary bedroom, two bedrooms, one bath and hall
Upper floor today · 3 bedrooms, 1 bath
Concept plan: new primary bedroom above the family room with bath and walk-in closet, renovated hall bath, and three more bedrooms
Upper floor concept · 4 bedrooms, 2 baths

Why the ADU comes first. This 5,000 sq ft lot is zoned R1-C, with a floor-area limit of 2,500 sq ft, and today the house and studio count about 2,430 sq ft toward it. Up to 800 sq ft of ADU space is exempt, so permitting the studio as an ADU frees room for the new suite: about 2,300 sq ft counted, under the limit.

Questions about this option? Mention it in your tour request.

Illustrative concept prepared by the owners from the City of San Mateo zoning map and Municipal Code (Title 27, including Chapter 27.19 on ADUs) as of November 2026. The studio is used as an office today; it is not a dwelling unit. Nothing shown has been designed, engineered, permitted or approved, and feasibility, size and cost are not confirmed. Square footage is approximate; the City determines floor area at plan review, and codes change. Buyers should confirm with the City of San Mateo Planning and Building divisions and consult their own architect, structural engineer and contractor.

Neighborhood

Baywood–Aragon, San Mateo

One of San Mateo's most established neighborhoods: 1920s–40s homes on tree-lined streets with sidewalks, minutes from downtown San Mateo, Caltrain and Highways 92, 101 and 280.

Distances are approximate straight-line miles. Tap a category to show or hide it.

Schools

  • Aragon High School — rated A+ by Niche; ranked #2 public high school in San Mateo County
  • Borel Middle School — rated A- by Niche; about a block away
  • Baywood Elementary — rated A by Niche
  • College of San Mateo — community college about 1.2 miles away on W. Hillsdale Blvd.
  • Nearby private schools — The Nueva School (Upper School at Bay Meadows), Crystal Springs Uplands, St. Matthew's, Serra, Notre Dame and Mercy

Public school assignment is set by the San Mateo-Foster City and San Mateo Union districts and can change; buyers should verify with each district.

Parks & outdoors

  • Central Park — playground, tennis, Japanese Tea Garden
  • Laurelwood Park & Sugarloaf Open Space — creekside playground and hiking trails
  • The Peninsula Golf & Country Club — private club with a Donald Ross–designed course, minutes away on Madera Drive
  • Beresford Park, Bay Tree Park and DeAnza Park
  • Crystal Springs & Sawyer Camp trails — a short drive via 92/280

Shops & dining

  • Downtown San Mateo — B Street boutiques, restaurants and Draeger's Market
  • 25th Avenue — independent shops and cafés
  • Hillsdale Shopping Center — Apple, Nordstrom, Williams Sonoma and dining

Getting around

  • Caltrain — Hayward Park and Hillsdale stations about 1–2 miles away, with electrified service to San Francisco and the South Bay
  • Highways 92, 101 & 280 — all close by
  • San Francisco to the north and Menlo Park, Palo Alto & Mountain View to the south
  • SFO — about 10 miles

Private Showings

Request a private tour

Tours are by appointment. Tell us two times that work and we'll confirm by email or phone. Buyers are asked to provide proof of funds or a lender pre-approval before the showing.

Buyers represented by an agent are welcome — please include your agent's name.